Research Reports

Allowing Established Clover to Grow with Corn

By 
Stefan Gailans
Dec 10, 2021
2021 Trial
12 minutes
Topics:
This research was funded by the Walton Family Foundation. 

In a Nutshell:

  • In recent years, several farmers have wondered about using clover as a companion cover crop or “living mulch” with corn. Such a strategy would increase the amount of time a legume cover crop is present in a crop rotation and possibly reduce the need to re-seed a cover crop each year.
  • Jack Boyer and Dick Sloan planted corn into a living clover cover crop and then chemically suppressed the clover to limit competition with the corn and with the intention for the clover to regrow later in the season. The clovers at both farms were eventually terminated, though, because of weed pressure.
  • Boyer and Sloan hypothesized that suppressing (and then eventually terminating) the clover cover crop would not harm corn yields compared to terminating the cover crop at corn planting.

Key Findings:

  • Results were mixed between the farms and this could be indicative of the slightly different experimental designs. Boyer saw better corn yields where he delayed clover termination compared to where he terminated a rye cover crop just prior to corn planting. Sloan, on the other hand, used only clover cover crops – he scored better corn yields where he terminated at corn planting compared to where he delayed clover termination.

Background

Cover cropping typically involves growing vegetation between the harvest and planting of cash crops. Companion cropping or living mulch strategies, on the other hand, involve growing cash crops alongside cover crops (e.g., the cover crop is not terminated). Research in the Midwest over the past 20 years has uncovered both the challenges and opportunities with this approach.[1] Challenges include competition for nutrients and moisture between the cash crop and companion, which can severely reduce cash crop yield.[2–5] In other words, the companion behaves like a weed. This challenge can be partially overcome by careful variety and species selection as well as suppression of the companion.[1,6] The opportunities and benefits of living mulch systems mirror those commonly associated with perennial groundcover: reduced soil erosion; improved soil fertility; improved soil water and temperature dynamics; forage for grazing livestock. Jack Boyer and Dick Sloan have incorporated small-grains crops into their rotations in recent years, which affords them the opportunity to use legume cover crops like red clover. Typically, the clover cover crop is terminated prior to planting corn and research suggests between 50 and 150 units of N fertilizer can be replaced with this practice.[7–9] In this project, Boyer and Sloan wanted to compare clover as a living mulch in their corn with the typical practice of terminating the cover crop. Weed pressure on both farms necessitated a herbicide pass in June that terminate the clovers; the resulting experiments effectively compared termination dates: at-plant vs. delayed.

Pic. 1
Dick Sloan planted corn on May 13, 2021 into red+alsike clover that was established with a triticale crop in April 2020.

Methods

Design

Boyer and Sloan conducted similar, but slightly different, experiments. Both raised a winter small grain in 2020 in order to establish the clover cover crop. Boyer seeded four strips of red clover and compared the following two treatments:

  • Delayed Clover Termination – Chemically suppress red clover at corn planting; terminate clover in June after corn emergence. Clover was interseeded to cereal rye seed crop in spring 2020.
  • At-Plant Rye Termination -- Terminate cereal rye

Sloan seeded his entire experiment to a blend of red clover and alsike clover and compared the following two treatments:

  • Delayed Clover Termination -- Chemically suppress clover cover crop at corn planting; terminate clover in June after corn emergence Clover was interseeded to triticale grain crop in spring 2020.
  • At-Plant Clover Termination -- Terminate clover cover crop at corn planting. Clover cover crop was interseeded to triticale grain crop in spring 2020.

Boyer implemented four replications of the two treatments (Figure A1) in strips measuring 15 ft wide by 2,100 ft long. Sloan implemented three replications of his two treatments (Figure A1) in strips measuring 30 ft wide by 1,620 ft long. Field management at both farms is presented in Table 1.

Table 1
Click to enlarge.
In early June 2021, both Boyer and Sloan observed heavy weed pressure (waterhemp, marestail) and elected to apply another round of herbicide. These applications ultimately terminated the clover in the ‘suppress’ treatments. Thus, the experiments effectively compared cover crops terminated at corn planting with cover crops terminated after corn emergence (delayed termination). Measurements Sloan collected samples of clover biomass from two representative locations (1 ft × 1 ft) in the field near the time of clover suppression and termination (May 20, 2021). Sloan weighed the samples after allowing them to air dry for 5 weeks. Sloan also collected corn stalk samples for nitrate assays on Oct. 10 and conducted stand counts in each strip just prior to harvest on Oct. 25. Boyer and Sloan harvested and recorded corn grain yields from each individual strip on Oct. 15 and Oct. 27, respectively. Grain yields were adjusted to 15.5% moisture.
Pic 2
Corn emerging on June 2, 2021 alongside red+alsike clover that was suppressed on May 10, 2021 at Dick Sloan's. The clovers were eventually terminated on June 24, 2021.
Data analysis To evaluate the effect of cover crop termination on corn, we calculated the least significant difference (LSD) a t-test for the difference in average yield between their two treatments was greater than the LSD, we would expect such a difference to occur 9 times out of 10 – we refer to this as a statistically significant effect. On the other hand, if the difference resulting from the two treatments was less than the LSD, we would consider the results to be statistically similar. We could make these statistical calculations because both Boyer’s and Sloan’s experimental designs involved replication of their two treatments (Figure A1).

Results and Discussions

Clover biomass

From samples he collected about one week after planting corn, Sloan determined that he planted corn into a clover stand of 4,118 lb/ac of biomass. In his Delayed Clover Termination strips, the clover was allowed to grow for an additional month before Sloan terminated on June 24 (Table 1). Cornstalk nitrate & plant population At Sloan’s, neither cornstalk nitrate concentrations nor plant populations just prior to harvest were affected by the clover termination date treatments (Table 2). For both treatments, stalk nitrate concentrations fell in the low category (<250 ppm), but this does not necessarily indicate nitrogen deficiency, according to Iowa State University Extension and Outreach.[10] Rather, it could be an indication of the corn having just enough nitrogen through the season.

Table 2
Click to enlarge.
Corn yield Boyer saw statistically greater corn yields by an average of 20 bu/ac where he delayed termination of the clover compared to where he terminated the rye cover crop at corn planting (Figure 1). Sloan conducted a slightly different trial than Boyer; opting for only clover cover crops preceding the corn. Where Sloan terminated the clovers at corn planting, he saw statistically superior corn yields by an average of 33 bu/ac compared to where he delayed termination of the clovers (Figure 2).
Fig. 1
FIGURE 1. Corn yields at Jack Boyer’s in 2021. Because the treatment averages differed by more than the least significant difference (LSD = 19 bu/ac), we consider the treatments statistically different. The Delayed Clover Termination treatment was the statistically superior treatment as indicated with an asterisk (*).
Fig. 2
FIGURE 2. Corn yields at Dick Sloan’s in 2021. Because the treatment averages differed by more than the least significant difference (LSD = 29 bu/ac), we consider the treatments statistically different. The At-Plant Clover Termination treatment was the statistically superior treatment as indicated with an asterisk (*).
At Sloan’s field day on June 29, 2021, both Sloan and Boyer shared observations of moisture stress in the corn in their respective delayed termination treatments. Both Boyer’s and Sloan’s farms saw precipitation well below average in 2021 (Figure A2). Both moisture stress and competition from clover cover crops that were insufficiently terminated have been cited as culprits of corn yield drag in previous experiments in Ontario[11] and Iowa.[12] This may well have been why Sloan saw reduced corn yields where he delayed termination of the clover cover crop compared to both the at-plant termination and the 5-year average for Buchanan County (208 bu/ac), where Sloan farms.[13] It is probably worth mentioning, though, that Sloan achieved his corn yields with only the nitrogen applied with the starter fertilizer at planting and the 60 units side-dressed in June (Table 1). This speaks to the ability for clover cover crops to replace synthetic forms of nitrogen in corn production. Despite low rainfall in June and July and delayed termination of clover, Boyer, observed no yield drag from delaying the termination of the clover; in fact, corn yields exceeded his county’s 5-year average by over 20 bu/ac (Grundy County = 207 bu/ac).[13] Rainfall in August was approximately twice the long-term average and that may have sufficiently improved soil moisture conditions (Figure A2). Additionally, nitrogen cycling from the decomposing red clover cover crop may have helped to boost yields compared to the rye cover crop terminated at corn planting.
Pic 3
Corn on the right from the Delayed Clover Termination treatment was visibly behind developmentally compared to the corn on the left from the At-Plant Clover Termination treatment at Dick Sloan’s on June 22, 2021.
Economic considerations We used partial budget analysis to compare economic outcomes of the two treatments at Boyer’s because of the disparity in costs of cover crop seed. Remember that the cereal rye in the At-Plant Rye Termination treatment at Boyer’s was a volunteer cover crop that was seeded from grain blown out the back of the combine during rye harvest in July 2020 (Table 1). The red clover seed in the Delayed Clover Termination treatment, however, was purchased and broadcast seeded in March 2020. Even when considering these costs, Boyer’s Delayed Clover Termination treatment bested the rye treatment by $87.84/ac (Table 3). The greater corn yields (by 20 bu/ac @ $5.50/ac) were enough to cover the cost of the red clover and then some.
Table 3
Click to enlarge.

Conclusions and Next Steps

From their results, both Boyer and Sloan expressed some hesitancy about adopting the practice of suppressing or delaying termination of a clover cover crop in corn. Boyer did see some promise to the practice, but came away from the experience wondering if it would be consistently feasible. Attempting to stunt the clover and create conditions where it would not interfere with the corn proved challenging. “I saw some opportunity for clover producing nitrogen, however, weed control became an issue,” he said. “The concept was good, but in practice, it was more difficult to implement successfully.” Sloan echoed Boyer’s concerns about weed pressure when intending to let clover grow beneath the corn canopy. “A suppressed clover crop can compete with a newly planted corn crop. If weed control becomes critical to save the corn, I won't gain any benefits later in the season and could further damage the corn in a dry year.” Instead, Sloan intends to keep using clover cover crops in his cropping system but will terminate it before planting corn because “clover after winter small grains improves my soil health and subsequent corn crops.” In a future trial, Sloan will compare a fall clover termination date with a spring termination date.

Appendix - Trial Design and Weather Conditions

Fig. A1
FIGURE A1. Sample experimental design used by the cooperators. The design involves replications of the two termination treatments and this allowed for statistical analysis of the results.
Fig A2
FIGURE A2. Mean monthly temperature and rainfall for 2021 and the long-term averages at the nearest weather stations to each farm. A) Boyer (Grundy Center); B) Sloan (Vinton).[15]

References

  1. Moore, K.J., R.P. Anex, A.E. Elobeid, S. Fei, C.B. Flora, A.S. Goggi, K.L. Jacobs, P. Jha, A.L. Kaleita, D.L. Karlen, D.A. Laird, A.W. Lenssen, T. Lübberstedt, M.D. McDaniel, D.R. Raman and S.L. Weyers. 2019. Regenerating agricultural landscapes with perennial groundcover for intensive crop production. Agronomy. 9: https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4395/9/8/458 (accessed November 2021).
  2. Sawyer, J.E., P. Pedersen, D.W. Barker, D.A. Ruiz Diaz and K. Albrecht. 2010. Intercropping corn and kura clover: Response to nitrogen fertilization. Agronomy Journal. 102:568–574. https://dl.sciencesocieties.org/publications/aj/abstracts/102/2/568 (accessed November 2021).
  3. Flynn, E.S., K.J. Moore, J.W. Singer and K.R. Lamkey. 2013. Evaluation of grass and legume species as perennial ground covers in corn production. Crop Science. 53:611–620. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1220&context=agron_pubs (accessed November 2021).
  4. Bartel, C.A., C. Banik, A.W. Lenssen, K.J. Moore, D.A. Laird, S. V. Archontoulis and K.R. Lamkey. 2017. Establishment of perennial groundcovers for maize-based bioenergy production systems. Agronomy Journal. 109:822–835. https://acsess.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.2134/agronj2016.11.0656 (accessed November 2021).
  5. Ochsner, T.E., T.W. Schumacher, R.T. Venterea, G.W. Feyereisen and J.M. Baker. 2018. Soil Water Dynamics and Nitrate Leaching Under Corn–Soybean Rotation, Continuous Corn, and Kura Clover. Vadose Zone Journal. 17:1–11. https://acsess.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.2136/vzj2017.01.0028 (accessed November 2021).
  6. Ziyomo, C., K.A. Albrecht, J.M. Baker and R. Bernardo. 2013. Corn performance under managed drought stress and in a Kura clover living mulch intercropping system. Agronomy Journal. 105:579–586. https://acsess.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.2134/agronj2012.0427 (accessed November 2021).
  7. Liebman, M., R.L. Graef, D. Nettleton and C.A. Cambardella. 2012. Use of legume green manures as nitrogen sources for corn production. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems. 27:180–191. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1202&context=stat_las_pubs (accessed November 2021).
  8. Gaudin, A., S. Westra, C. Loucks, K. Janovicek, R. Martin and W. Deen. 2013. Improving Resilience of Northern Field Crop Systems Using Inter-Seeded Red Clover: A Review. Agronomy. 3:148–180. https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4395/3/1/148 (accessed November 2021).
  9. Gailans, S. and T. Sieren. 2014. Nitrogen Replacement Value of Red Clover. Practical Farmers of Iowa Cooperators’ Program. https://practicalfarmers.org/research/nitrogen-replacement-value-of-red-clover/ (accessed November 2021).
  10. Sawyer, J. and A.P. Mallarino. 2018. Cornstalk Testing to Evaluate Nitrogen Management. PM 1584. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. https://store.extension.iastate.edu/product/Use-of-the-End-of-Season-Corn-Stalk-Nitrate-Test-in-Iowa-Corn-Production (accessed November 2021).
  11. Vyn, T.J., J.G. Faber, K.J. Janovicek and E.G. Beauchamp. 2000. Cover Crop Effects on Nitrogen Availability to Corn following Wheat. Agronomy Journal. 915–924. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2000.925915x (accessed November 2021).
  12. Gailans, S.R. 2017. Evaluating alternative , diverse cropping systems that include canola , wheat , and red clover in Iowa. Thesis. Iowa State University. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7139&context=etd.
  13. US Department of Agriculture-National Agricultural Statistics Service. Quick stats. USDA-National Agricultural Statistics Service. https://quickstats.nass.usda.gov/ (accessed November 2021).
  14. Plastina, A. 2021. 2021 Iowa Farm Custom Rate Survey. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. https://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/crops/pdf/a3-10.pdf (accessed November 2021).
  15. Iowa Environmental Mesonet. 2021. Climodat Reports. Iowa State University. http://mesonet.agron.iastate.edu/climodat/ (accessed November 2021).